Notes/Thoughts/Questions
** click the number to see personal thoughts**
- Do you think once a moment is gone, it’s gone forever? What does your concept of time look like?
- Death is an afterthought to many people until it is their time to go. People speculate on how they’ll pass until they are face to face with death.
- Death acts like one of those beads on the string
4. ” Like so many Americans, she was trying to construct a life that has made sense from things she found in gift shops
Americans don’t build their own lives, they build it based on what is pushed to them. They look for meaning in material things instead of searching inward. They are always searching outward. Grabbing at things that don’t necessarily fit, or they think they are entitled too. They see life as a gift but don’t treat it as such. It’s something that you can decorate and make pretty with materials to fill whatever spots they need but rarely ever do they actually live it. They’ll buy it though
5. The Execution of Slavic
He was killed because he challenged authority. Many people are used as examples to instill fear in others and keep them in check. That method never works for long. You will always have people who are not scared of the consequences of doing what is right.
6. Whenever we go from place to place or memory to memory, it reminds me of listening to my grandparents tell stories of the past. It’s like they are also transported through time and space and are back in the same body, age, and time that the memory took place. It’s like when people get that faraway look in their eyes when remembering. It also reminds me of being shellshocked.
“Where has the time gone?” page 72, When Billy’s mom asked ” When did I get so old?”
6. We often ignore veterans and their stories. Just like we watch the news and comment ” Oh that’s so sad” and then move on with our lives. We see the effects of war and encourage people to talk about it but ignore them in the process. It goes on through one ear and right out of our ass when we talk about war and its impact to others.
EX: Billy’s treatment when he’s trying to sleep in the train and people keep telling him no, they don’t want to risk ruining their own small bubble of comfort to help someone who really needs it. No empathy or compassion is there for Billy from the others(1). When Billy tried telling Lily and Rumford he was there at Dresden but they dismissed him.
7. The prayer that Billy keeps on his wall is the prayer for people who are selfish and passive. They don’t even understand what the passage really means so they use it as a security blanket for not taking action. People run this phrase into the ground but still don’t have the courage to change the things they have the power to do. They sit and become comfortable because they refuse to acquire the knowledge and power to help make differences.
8. ” Everybody turned into a baby, and humanity, without exception, conspired biologically to produce two perfect people named Adam and Eve. ” page 95
9. Is the alien abduction a metaphor for him trying to kill himself or the past seizing and holding him in place so that he can’t move on?
10. Describing PTSD like living in a zoo seems like a good analogy
You are trapped in the past that acts as a cage where time moves forward but you don’t. You can watch everyone age and everyone can watch you, but you are unaware of yourself, time, and aging.
11. Weary blamed Billy for his death when it should have been directed at the people who sent him to fight. People blame everyone but the governing bodies who waged the war in the first place. These governing bodies use our nationalism and pride against us and turn it into weapons. They use the hero and savior complexes of our young and twist them into dreams that are not their own. All to send theme to their deaths so that they can continue to profit.
12. What Do We Take From the Dead?
We take anything that we can from the dead and use it for our own personal gain/satisfaction. We take their prized possessions, their last words, their last wishes, and their memories. Yet we do nothing with the things that we take, except make ourselves feel good. When some of us encounter death, they are always pleased that it was the other person and not them. We use their stories of life and struggle and turn it into kind of lesson. We don’t truly honor the dead. We just see it as another milestone in life that we’ll reach someday as well. We celebrate the deaths of others while dreading our own. We make ourselves sick and miserable imagining the how and when. We forget how much we’ll be shared in our end. We forget that the passed should be celebrated. Just because their moment is gone doesn’t mean you can’t enjoy it once more. It’s like the milestones that we reached in life don’t even matter anymore.
13. ” Earthlings are great explainers. Explaining why this event is structured as it is, telling how other events may be achieved or avoided… All time is time. It does not change or lend itself to warnings or explanations… we are all bugs in amber.” page 109
We as humans are always looking for reasons. Always looking for the why and the how, getting ourselves so hung up. Especially when it comes to war and life. Those who have never experienced talk about war from an intellectual standpoint. They only educate through books and think they know why wrong is wrong. They don’t bother to listen to real accounts and base their views on books alone. They are so blind to cyclical pattern that is war and its causes. War and death, the patterns are all the same. Senseless and unavoidable. We cannot avoid any of these things. Wars happen because greed will always exist in this world. We are trapped in this endless cycle of war and death. Time and time again, the conditions will repeat itself, because that’s what history does. We are doomed to repeat the bad just as we are blessed to repeat the good. We exist in the past, present, and the future. We exist in all time. You would think because we immortalize these conditions that we can somehow avoid them. But it’s only history to them but they are unaware that it will become a memory they wish to forget. They only live in these memories short term, the people who actually experienced, live in these memories all time. They are forever stuck. Like the bugs in the amber. We think we twist time to our will, force it to do our bidding, in order to achieve what we want. We focus so much on timelines and periods. When is the right time? Is it the wrong time? When will my time come? Am I going to do this in my lifetime? We do all this to forget we are stuck in the time that we are in. Times definitely change, but everything is cyclical. We keep learning that war is wrong but for some reason keep repeating. We only know it’s wrong because we say so. We are so stuck on our amber that we are blind to how much we are immersed in the amber of the past and of the one poured by your government. They will tell you that it’s all senseless violence when it is not. It’s premeditated and already justified. Death and the suffering of others okay because we all have to die someday. They will virtue signal all day long but do nothing to stand against it. Their fingers and eyes are ambered to the pages or whatever they are forced to see. They don’t listen to people who fought in the wars, only what is shown to them through books or propaganda. They call things that look vaguely correct on social media truth without ever looking deeper. They ignore the stories and accounts from people actually living. Anything to be able to explain away the guilt they feel for not helping or shedding light on issues they have the power to stop.
14. Calling Germans ” Jerry”
It feels like an attempt to take blame away from an entire group by giving them a nickname that sounds like it belongs to one person. Maybe it makes it easier to be mad at a whole group by lumping them into one persona. It kind of reminds me of calling people from the Middle East ” Hussain”
15. Of course the doctors at the institution didn’t think the war was what was causing his Billy’s mental breakdown. If they admitted that, they would be forced to look at how sending people to their deaths to fight for causes they don’t even have all the information about can truly take a toll on one’s psyche.
16. ” People would be surprised if they knew how much in this world was due to prayers” pg. 131
It’s like hearing ” thoughts and prayers” whenever there is a school shooting. It also just diminishes the hard work of others. That’s not to say prayers can’t be answered but there is hard work of another or someone else involved.
17. ” We’ve had to imagine the war here, and we imagined that it was being fought by aging men like ourselves. We had forgotten that wars were fought by babies… ” pg 135
I don’t think most people or officials understand that we are losing our youth to these wars. As long as they are not the ones who’s fighting or their sons who are fighting, then the loss of your child is okay. We recruit these not even of high school children to fight for causes they know nothing about. They barely know about the world and are chock full of unchecked nationalism if they have not yet been jaded or scorned by life. Officials and your government bank on the hope of young children wanting to change to world and turn it into a nightmare.
18. ” … There isn’t anything we can do about them, so we simply don’t look at them. We simply ignore them- we spend eternity looking at a pleasant moments… That’s the one thing earthlings might learn to do, if they tried hard enough: Ignore the awful times and concentrate on the good ones.” page 150
This reminds me of a post that I saw where someone said ” Joy is a form of Resistance”. I think they failed to mention that the sentiment only works if you are also doing other things to resist. You are just going on about your life and feeling joy does nothing for the people actually suffering. It’s the same as being a performative activist. Posting yellow squares is not enough. Many Americans do not give a shit about things that don’t concern the country until their comfortable way of life is impacted. It’s dumb and it’s one of the reasons why people hate us overseas. Americans are selfish and only think of their own countries and lives.
19. ” … Poor Americans are urged to hate themselves…” pg 164
One of the worst things to be is poor, outside of being a minority, being poor on top of that is the worst. Everyone hates you and thinks the worst of you. They don’t know you but they assume things about you. They think you don’t deserve the simple things in life like candy or entertainment systems. They police the kind of help you get and look down on you when you do. They only care about where their tax dollars are going when poor people are involved but not when the military spends every penny of their tax dollars or the government bails out other foreign nations. Poor people will always be outsiders looking in, even when they do get a little money, people police how they’re supposed to spend it because they think they know best. Everyone always thinks they know best when it comes to other peoples money, ignoring the societal and financial factors that we are operating under.
20. The rich count on your self hatred so that you never make it out the mud. They’ll give you some tools but will make it incredibly hard for most to access it. Even though we have classes and information available to us, it costs. College education if one wants to pursue is a luxury. The rich will never have the common man’s interest in mind. It is an afterthought as they don’t want to share power or wealth. Trump promised groceries would be lower yet is having a tariff war with the nation that is basically our landlord and where we get most of our product from. Lots of promising but nothing that is good for the working or lower class. It’s why they don’t want us to be a community use so many things to divide us. If we band together and actually respect and love one another then it would be a lot harder for us to hate ourselves and protect every other poor person.
21. ” If you protest, if you think that death is a terrible thing, then you have not understood a word I’ve said.” pg 181
Death is scary to those who do not know how to cherish life. Those who have packed their life with real and true meaning know that death isn’t the end. It’s only a moment in time but they have learned that they exist in every moment of time. They are more alive in death than they’ll ever be in life. They able to reach places or rooms they’ve never been. Their reach is everlasting. They’ll live forever in the hearts of those who love them and in exist forever in thoughts of those who hate them or are intrigued by them. Some people can find joy in death. My family and I, while we are saddened by the passing of our loved ones, we celebrate and talk to them as if they are still there. Because they are. It’s simply that their moment is passing. When they’re gone, they’re gone but that moment will come around again. We will always have memories and can exist in those memories with them. Death is the one bead that’s always going to be on the thread of life and there’s not much you can do to change that moment.
22. ” One of the main effects of war is that people are discouraged from being characters.”
Soldiers and Americans are conditioned to be a unit. Any personality that exist or they’re cultivating is beaten or persuaded out of them. It just turns them into perfect little soldiers or dumbing them down to consumer lapdogs who say yes to any policy change and don’t bat an eye. They are just weapons or means to an end
23. People view war as black and white. If they find you live in the county that is doing “bad things”, they want to lump you in as a group and condemn you all to die. However in that group there are people who are working to stop the destruction just as you are and should do well to remember the innocents. No one ever remembers the innocents.
24. Billy’s son Robert is an example of what people think the military is supposed to do for down and out kids. You just throw them in a war and hope that the experience teaches them discipline and obedience since that’s all you need in life. It’s hard to make something of yourself in an environment that completely strips away everything you are/were and you come out a person who the government thinks is worthy of valor, praise, and respect.