
I’ve never had Indian food before this year. No naan, curries, masalas, or chutneys of any kind lmao. However this year is different.
I’ve kind of been making it my mission to try new food whether I cook it or go to a restaurant. It’s been working out well, but I feel like I am picky eater in disguise. I can’t say I don’t like something if I’ve never tried it. Sometimes I just get in my own way of enjoying something new because I can’t imagine how it tastes. It would help out greatly if I started tasting more things so I can get a better judge of flavor.
I’m only giving this long winded section that people normally hate about recipes because it applies to the situation. I’m incredibly clueless when it comes to this specific asian cuisine. The flavors are unknown to me and I have no idea what goes into the dishes; so I unfortunately and Americanly avoided trying something new. All I knew was that it always smelled and looked amazing.
Butter Chicken is kind of like the new Orange Chicken to my understanding. Not flavor wise but foreign food being popular in America wise.
The first time I had butter chicken it was a frozen meal from Trader Joe’s. I thought it was good, but I knew I was missing out flavor wise since frozen meals never capture the real thing well enough. This year I tried a new butter chicken that wasn’t from Joe’s but it was from Deep. That was much better and I gathered a better flavor profile. So good that I decided that I wanted to try to and make it myself because buying it was getting too expensive.
I did ask my Indian coworkers for any tips or must have ingredients and they were all very helpful in giving suggestions( Luv ya’ll ). The main thing I gathered from their tips is that it’s tomato based and lots of stirring lol.
So let’s get into my process.

I always say that I don’t need to buy too much every time I go to the store but I’m going to be honest this time and admit that I only had the rice at home. Sadly it was not Basmati rice but in my defense groceries are too expensive and I was on a budget.
You can certainly use real tomatoes instead of sauce from a can but I don’t have the tools at my disposal to do that. If you would like to donate to the blender fund please let me know.
The only thing I did differently than the recipe was, as per the suggestion of my boyfriend, that I salt and tenderize my chicken and let it sit up to 30 minutes. It’s supposed to make the chicken moist or something like that. I think it worked. The chicken wasn’t dry and was juicy.
The cooking process wasn’t too bad. My coworkers were right about one tip, it is tomato based. The stirring part wasn’t that bad so maybe I misheard.
Despite the name, not a lot of butter is needed, but then again, I feel like I’m making an americanized recipe so I could be wrong. I only used bit of butter when I was cooking the chicken. I did put in some oil to see if I could try and crisp it up like the recipe was saying but I feel like I put too much butter in mine. It still turned out fine.
I only used what I could describe as a handful of ginger lmao. You can see in the ingredients pic how much ginger I used. It was probably half of the relatively small ginger I bought.

I think the recipe used 5 cloves of garlic but I only used 4. I wasn’t trying to pussy out or anything, 4 just felt better for the portions that I had. The recipe calls for you to only smash the garlic, not mince, and to leave it in the for the entire process so that the flavor can gather. I would say don’t forget to take them out unless you like eating garlic cloves. I’m sure it’ll probably taste good.

The rest of the process wasn’t too bad. It does help to put your chicken to one side of the pan while the garlic and the ginger cook together.
The most exciting part about all of this was adding the heavy whipping cream. I’m a big slut for putting cream in things. I love putting it in my soups or ramen broths. It just elevates the flavor.
I was concerned that I used too much tomato sauce because it was so rich, but I think I was just unfamiliar with Butter Chicken’s game. It’s incredibly rich and flavorful. In fact, I was upset that I didn’t have more sauce.
Another small win was that my potion sizes were incredible. I made enough for just me and my boyfriend, no seconds unfortunately.
That’s lowkey kinda good cause this was the most heartburn inducing meal I’ve ever had.
Still I loved it. It was easy to make and I’m happy to add another recipe to my arsenal. It was so good we had it twice in one week.
I probably would’ve loved it more if I had a mango lassi tbh but cream soda is a nice substitute.
Thxs Shay ❤





